All Posts Tagged: stimulus

Labor Market Devastation – Who Is Bearing the Brunt?

Scott Anderson
Chief Economist

The widespread business shutdowns that began in mid-March to try to contain the rapidly spreading coronavirus led to millions of Americans being thrown out of work.

In just a short two months since nonfarm payrolls peaked in February 2020, 21.4 million jobs have been lost, nearly erasing the approximately 22.8 million jobs gained during the record-long economic expansion that lasted for over 10 and a half years.

The unprecedented speed of job losses, which differentiates this downturn from previous ones, pushed the unemployment rate up from an expansion-low of 3.5% in February to 14.7% in April, the highest since the BLS began recording official statistics in 1948. To put the 14.7% into context, the peak unemployment rate during the Great Recession was 10.0% when a “mere” 8.7 million jobs were erased over 18 months.

Digging beneath the obvious labor market devastation helps one see a little clearer who is bearing the brunt of the economic pain at this juncture. Looking at unemployment by educational attainment, we see that workers with more education have been relatively insulated.

Those with at least a bachelor’s degree experienced the smallest unemployment rate increase of 6.5 percentage points, while those without a high school diploma suffered the largest unemployment rate increase of 15.5 percentage points over the past two months.

Older workers have also gotten hit harder than they have in recessions in the past. Younger workers always seem to experience the biggest unemployment rate increases during recessions while older age cohorts see a smaller rise. Young age cohorts have seen big increases this time too, but older workers in 45-54 and 55+ category have also seen hefty increases in unemployment of 9.8% and 11.0% respectively.

When the data is segmented by sex, males normally suffer a bigger increase in unemployment than females during recessions. However, in this downturn the unemployment rate increase for females (12.8%) easily exceeds that of males (9.9%). Therefore, the early stages of the economic downturn appear to have been particularly painful for women as well.

The Labor Market Outlook
There is considerable uncertainty regarding the shape of the U.S. economic recovery. The uncertainty predominantly stems from the uncertainty regarding the spread and containment of COVD-19 infections and how quickly consumer confidence and spending can recover to more normal levels.

Our baseline economic outlook is for a U-shaped recovery which is characterized by a sharp two-quarter recession followed by a gradual return to the prior peak. Under this scenario, the unemployment rate peaks at 20.5% in the third quarter of 2020 and remains in the double digits through the fourth quarter of 2021.

A more optimistic or a V-shaped recovery could be possible if a viable vaccine surfaced before year-end. In this scenario we could see sharp bounce back in economic activity that mirrors the steep decline that precipitated it. A second sizable stimulus package from Congress would further turbo charge the recovery. The U.S. unemployment rate in this scenario peaks at 18.1% in the second quarter of this year and falls to below 7.0% by the fourth quarter of next year.

A more pessimistic W-shaped recovery or a double-dip recession could unfold if we see significant reemergence of virus cases and a return of widespread business lockdowns. The U.S. unemployment could move above 30% by the first quarter of 2021 in this scenario and remain near Great Depression levels throughout next year.

Regardless of the shape the recovery ultimately takes, one thing is certain, the contraction that precedes it will prove to be one for the record books and will be studied by economists for years.

To find out more, check out this week’s U.S. Outlook Report.
==

Read More ›

Federal Government to the Rescue

Scott Anderson
Chief Economist

For the first time since the Great Recession, people are again using words like “unprecedented” and “uncharted territory” to describe the current economic and financial environment as business shutdowns and layoffs quickly follow the virus’s spread around the world.

Read More ›

U.S. Outlook: Market fears of near-term recession overblown

Scott Anderson
Chief Economist
Busy work environment with stock traders concentrating on their computers.

As recently as September when U.S. stocks were hitting new record highs, economic optimism was rampant and, in retrospect, probably overdone.

Read More ›

U.S. Outlook: Let the tax reform fight begin

Scott Anderson
Chief Economist
US Capitol dome seen in middle distance on a sunny fall day with lawn and reddish-leaf trees in the foreground.

We are finally getting some concrete details on the size and shape of the likely tax reform package that is moving through the House.

Read More ›

Investment Insights: Excerpts from our Q3 strategy report

Wade Balliet
Posted by Wade Balliet
Investment Strategy
European Central Bank, Frankfurt

We see emerging markets and smaller companies as a possible opportunity, but we are underweight to those areas in the current environment.

Read More ›